This post is tied to the episode of Aggressive Negotiations on The Nerd Party that’s released on April 9. Subscribe now for a fascinating discussion that sprang from this topic!

This post is basically an expanded look at the starting point, and we go in some interesting directions I won’t cover below. After all, to quote Darth Tyranus, “This is just the beginning!”

Why the New Republic Fell So Easily

A lot of ideas have been bandied about the Star Wars fan base about what went wrong with the New Republic in the years after Return of the Jedi, that allowed it to be wiped off the face of the galaxy between the single moment Hosnian Prime gets obliterated in The Force Awakens and during the short intermission before The Last Jedi.

There are countless flashy theories, and even Expanded Universe material to set up a grand vision of Sheev Palpatine setting a plan in motion to burn the house down on his way out. I think the solution is much more simple, beautiful, and requires no additional materials, sentinel droids, or people named “Gallius Rax.”

The Death Star Conference Room in Star Wars A New Hope which was called Star Wars in 1977 and featured the Death Star Conference Room and is the only Star Wars movie to feature a Death Star Conference Room since the only other Star Wars movies with Death Stars feature battle bridges and hallways and the Emperor's Throne Room but not the Death Star Conference Room in a Star Wars movie. I can't believe I just repeated Death Star Conference Room and Star Wars so much the words have lost all meaning.
“Next on the agenda, the proposal for more comfortable chairs. Good grief, is anyone else’s back bothering them?”

Remembering a Key Moment from Star Wars: Episode IV: A New Hope

“The Imperial Senate will no longer be of any concern to us. I’ve just received word that the Emperor has dissolved the council permanently. The last remnants of the Old Republic have been swept away.”

“But how will the Emperor maintain control, without the bureaucracy?”

“The regional governors now have direct control over their territories. Fear will keep the local systems in line.”

– Grand Moff Tarkin & General Tagge, Star Wars

This is the most beautiful, simple explanation. It doesn’t even require reading additional materials; anyone who knows me, knows I hate that dodge.

How eloquent it is, that the New Republic was destined for trouble, and eventual failure, by the fact that Palpatine dismantled the mechanism of representative government. If the Empire was defined by his Sith will, and carried out by those personally loyal to him, with no mechanism for how things would work without a clear ascendant.

As a side note, I think one of the most flawed things envisioned in the post-Return of the Jedi storyline is that of Imperial forces unified in any substantive way. Palpatine gave power to people who were specifically antagonistic.

The war of personalities around that conference table on the Death Star is just one example of the type of people who were in Sidious’ Empire. Piett’s flagrant currying of favor with Vader, at the expense of Ozzell, shows two more people who would have been at each other’s throats in a power vacuum. Rogue One: A Star Wars Story shows this even more explicitly through the animosity and political maneuvering between Tarkin and Director Krennic.

Ben Mendelssohn as Director Krennic in Rogue One, who's a snappier dresser than Grand Moff Tarkin, but still not as great a dresser as Craigula, who isn't in Rogue One A Star Wars Story, which is a movie featuring Director Krennic.
Say what you want, he was a pretty snappy dresser.

Listen to Aggressive Negotiations for a Deeper Dive

Every revolution leaves a mess in its wake. What binds those who rebelled together no longer holds true after the rulers are deposed. Sometimes it breaks for the better, like the American Revolutionaries who spent a decade finding a workable method of government. Sometimes it breaks for the worse, like the French Revolutionaries who came to sate their righteous fury with innocent blood.

Matt Rushing and I pick up this topic and explore the implications of what came before, and try to make sense of what came after as we start with a look at what Palpatine did to set up the New Republic for failure.

Advertisements