The Batman Blogs: Coda

I’m wrapping up this series with a slightly more personal look at things, because that’s how I am. I think I’d disappoint everyone, myself included, if I didn’t. It’s not going to be too long, I swear. I’ll also fold in the key character to whom I’ve not given enough attention, Alfred.

It’s just going to be why I love the character of Batman so darn much.

Batman is better than just about any comics character; old-school Wolverine is an exception, but not the kinder, softer Wolverine. The one who took a sword through the neck and still kicked the s*** out of Silver Samurai.

Batman Is More Real

Batman is better than any of the other because he’s the most believable.

I know, the tale of a millionaire/billionaire who uses his fortune to turn himself into a one–man army in order to clean up corruption and crime is a bit far–fetched. It’s more than a little impractical, too. But there’s more emotional truth to this character than others.

The “outsider” take on Superman is a modern invention; if anything, I think they’ve cribbed it from Batman to give Superman a little more cred in the modern day. We’re all skeptical of our heroes and prefer them with big glaring flaws now, as opposed to tried-and-true symbols of perfection.

So anyway, Batman has always rung true with me. I could understand why he was the way he was. He didn’t luck into super powers (Spider-Man) and he didn’t even have the advantage of those sort of powers to begin with. He was motivated by pain, and then by the higher calling to lift that pain from others. Batman was a character who actually grew into his role of protector. He’s not on a nihilistic revenge kick anymore (Punisher), he’s actually acting to prevent others from going through what he endured.

A Little Help from His Friends

He’s also what I’d call a “realistic loner.”

By that I mean, he likes to think he’s alone in this world in no small way. He is the lone actor in his drama. But he’s got a hell of a supporting cast, headed by Alfred.

Alfred’s not an authority figure like a parent. He’s the stalwart model of a sympathetic friend. The one who stands by your side even when you’re a complete dick, because he understands why you’re being that way and knows that you’re a good person inside. He nudges and suggests, never imposing his perspective on Batman but letting him take advantage of his wisdom when he asks.

Through the years in the comics, Batman has eventually gathered a small network of support, from Barbara Gordon to Lucius Fox, Dick Grayson to Jason Todd. While I’m not a particular fan of Robin as a character, he does underline the need of Bruce Wayne to try to find a family of sorts, though he’s too dysfunctional to maintain a real one. Alfred is a foster father, Robin an adopted son. So this lone wolf character shows the precise importance of friends and family to surviving the burdens of life.

The Difference Between Law and Justice

Gotham City over time has come to represent what happens to society when people, not laws, are the arbiters of justice.

Gotham is a warning tale based on a very real situation that so many cities have found themselves in when laws are flouted by those with enough political clout to get around them. Sure, everyone picks on New York City through time, but Washington, D.C. is a great example, too. Not for the jackals in the federal government alone, but the local political machines are a lot like Chicago (though much less competent, and on a smaller scale). I mean, really. Marion Barry’s still on the City Council for goodness’ sake.

Batman is the one who refuses to bow to pressure or conventional wisdom and just accept things as they are. There are laws and there are rules, and someone has to enforce them fairly or everything goes to s***.

And of course he has to break the law to maintain it, raising the whole question to another level.

Revolutionary Batman.

The Dark Knight Returns naturally defined Batman for an entire generation. Without it, 1989’s Batman would have been lighter than it was. I truly believe that. Frank Miller showed the audience what it had been craving for a long time; a Batman that could have existed (with a little suspension of disbelief) in our world. A Batman that was not just motivated by what happened to his parents, but at the fact that when he retired, Gotham didn’t just revert to its filthier truth, it got worse.

The Dark Knight was released during an era of deep, dark crime in places like New York. Times Square wasn’t the bustling Broadway showcase for Disney that it is now. If you look at a lot of the movies of the 1980s, the vision of the near future is very dystopian, rooted in the belief that the cities were going to get so bad that we’d be lucky to survive. (Personal favorite: Escape from New York.)

And so Batman was reborn as the avatar of justice again; But this time he wasn’t motivated by personal tragedy alone. This time he was a man unable to withstand the disgusting truth of what humans can do to each other for the sake of thrills and money. But in this world, he wasn’t hailed as a hero but regarded an outlaw.

His natural enemy became Superman. And not to spoil anything, but Batman had issues with him.

If you haven’t read it, I’d have to say that Miller’s tome was undoubtedly formative on the world outlook of at least one young boy who learned to regard some things just a bit differently after reading it. Some of it stuck with him. Some of it should stick with all of us.

One More Thing

And finally, the crux of it all, is that Batman is plain old smart and determined. Other superheroes can get out of a jam because they can move super fast or whatever. And so the writers have to come up with even more extraordinary ways to get them into trouble.

Batman deals with problems like someone threatening to poison the reservoir (this was the Joker’s standard introduction to the storyline for many years). No Kryptonite, no super cousins, no power armor like Iron Man or invincibility like Wolverine.

Just a man with wits, will and the means to leverage them.

What’s not to love?

3 thoughts on “The Batman Blogs: Coda

  1. Wolverine took a sword to the neck. The sword went through his gut when Silver Samurai ran it through both of them as Wolverine was perched on his back. One of the best dialogue-free action sequences by an artist, Paul Smith, when the X-Men were still the best read in comics 🙂

    I agree with your points on the other stuff. Dark Knight returns is especially a classic for any age and anyone who denies that is simply pretending it’s “just a comic book”. A brilliant work.


  2. I heartily disagree with your take on Alfred, in part because your description describes my own dad so well.
    “The one who stands by your side even when you’re a complete dick, because he understands why you’re being that way and knows that you’re a good person inside. He nudges and suggests, never imposing his perspective on [you] but letting him take advantage of his wisdom when he asks.”

    That really doesn’t describe “parent” to you? Interesting. Personal stuff aside, you’re also overlooking the parental scene in the ’89 version where Alfred has dinner with Bruce and Vickie Vail in the kitchens and he tells a story about teaching Bruce horse back riding, and ends on, “that’s enough embarrassment for Bruce tonight, I’m going to bed, leave me the dishes”, and Bruce goes on to tell Vickie that Alfred is his family.

    In ’08 Dark Knight, Alfred reads the note from Rachel, and then destroys it, never giving it to Bruce and protecting his feelings.

    If that’s not parental, I don’t know what is.


  3. Thanks for the comments!

    I just said he wasn’t an authority figure – parents are friends too. But while a parent may stand by and support, there are also moments and put aside emotion to make sure they take their medicine and learn their lessons. It’s a tough line to walk, and one I occasionally hate to (I’m the softy parent most of the time, and the girls know that I cave under pressure from time to time). 🙂

    I will point out a few other things:
    Alfred is a servant to “Master Bruce”, which undercuts a major authority line.

    Ra’s al Ghul is much more a father to Bruce, as he follows in Ghul/Ducard’s footsteps. This is in comics and the current films.

    Above I write: “Alfred is a foster father, Robin an adopted son.”

    Arguably there will always be a little more distance between a foster parent or loving uncle than between you and your own folks (provided you knew them). I adore my mother in law, and love my father in law, but they’re not in the same exact position of authority as Mom and Dad were.


Comments are closed.